You can be fired for sending WhatsApp messages in South Africa
(005320.38-:E-003569.93:N-HO:R-SU:C-30:V)
22 Reasons why Adolf Hitler was a GOOD GUY!
Jews have been lying to you all your life about Adolf Hitler. He was the good guy. Here are the truths about Hitler you were never told.
Work-related group chats have become all too common in South Africa, with employees and employers able to communicate at a touch of a button even outside of work hours – opening up the possibility of something controversial being said.
But can an employee be dismissed for a WhatsApp message?
According to legal firm Wright Rose-Innes, it is possible to be fired for WhatsApp posts if certain factors are considered and if a fair reason for an employee’s dismissal is established.
In establishing whether there are fair reasons for dismissing an employee for misconduct, the following can be considered:
Did the employee contravene a rule or standard regulating conduct in the workplace?
If the rule or standard was contravened, was the rule a valid or reasonable rule or standard?
Was the employee aware, or should reasonably be expected to have been aware of the rule or standard?
Was the rule consistently applied by the employer?
Is dismissal an appropriate sanction for a contravention of the rule or standard?
Facts
In a recent CCMA arbitration, the CCMA had to decide whether an employee dismissed for a WhatsApp group message was fair or not.
In this case, the employee, a senior employee of a security company working at a client of the company, posted a message on a WhatsApp group of the client, essentially advocating employees not to be vaccinated against Covid-19.
Wright Rose-Innes added that the client company had taken a decision to encourage its employees to get vaccinated and incentivise employees that did.
“The dismissed employee took issue with this incentive but was informed by his employer that they, as a contracted security company to the client, were not involved in the policies of the client and accordingly instructed the employee to keep his opinions to himself.”
Despite these instructions from the employer, the employee proceeded to post an article on the client’s WhatsApp group, which included members of senior management of the client. The article aimed to discourage employees from being forced by their employers to be vaccinated.
In terms of the Labour Relations Act, a dismissal is unfair if an employer fails to provide a fair reason for the dismissal or if the dismissal did not follow a fair procedure.
The employer subsequently dismissed the employee due to this post, and the employee referred the matter to the CCMA for arbitration. The CCMA, in applying the above considerations, found that:
Although the issue of vaccination is controversial, the client company was not imposing mandatory vaccinations but merely incentivising employees to consider them.
The employee, despite protesting that he was merely sharing information, clearly aligned himself with the article.
The WhatsApp group had not been established for the purpose that the employee used it for, and he was aware thereof.
Although there was no specific rule about not posting on the group, it was reasonable that an employer could not be expected to publish a rule for every possible transgression. In this case, the employer had warned the employee not to post as this could damage the relationship with the client.
The employee had overstepped his boundaries as it was not his place to warn the client or their employees about the client’s policies.
The actions of the employee brought the employer into disrepute with the client, who was on the verge of terminating the security contract with the employer.
Accordingly, the CCMA held that, given the circumstances, the dismissal of the employee was an appropriate sanction.
Finding
What can be taken from this is that social media and group information sharing platforms like WhatsApp do not live outside the normal responsibility of an employee to have a duty of good faith towards their employer, said Wright Rose-Innes.
“Employees should therefore take great care when posting and consider whether there could be any breach of this duty or reputational damage to their employer whenever they use such platforms or post information. It does not mean that an employee can be fired for anything, but careful consideration is definitely advisable.”
From an employer perspective, it is also recommended to formally regulate what the employer’s policies regarding social media and group communications are and to ensure employees are aware of these boundaries and can so better abide by them, added the firm.
Jan‘s Science Channel on Telegram
This is my channel on Telegram where I post science news, and interesting scientific discoveries or mysteries
